Dear folks,
I have also read both the Discovery new and the Nature's brief comment
on the vestimentiferan worms. And there is one thing that immediately
arise from the comparison of both texts, independent of the fact that you
may trust on the scientific methods or not. This is, how a partial
intrepretation of scientific studies by newsman (always looking for high
impact news) produce silly ideas (I am sure that most of us will
immediately think on many examples of this).
For instance, the comment about corals as non-colonial organisms.
Although there are some solitary corals, these organisms are probably
the best known example of colonial animals. Also the comment on
palatability. Most organisms living in vent communities are adapted to the
presence of chemicals in the water, so the accumulation of these
materials in the potential preys might not discourage an adapted predator
to feed on it. This may only be valid for transient predators. The final
comment on extinction is also typical example of what newsman are
looking forward to hear from scientist.
On the other hand, I do not know if the title of the paper is an authors'
choice or not (maybe the original one was modified by the editors) but it
seems to me that the use of the word "record" is non-pertinent.
According to my colleagues working on sponges, there are -among
others- some slow-growing, long-living, deep water hexactinellid sponges
that may live for 100s of years, even 5 centuries. And sponges, although
"primitive" organisms, are non-colonial too. However, I am not certain if
there are some study published on this (if anybody knows, the
information will be welcome). Maybe some of our list members also
knows about longliving organisms which may be considered records but
has not been published in Nature.
Wormly,
Daniel.
Dr. Daniel Martin
Cientifico Titular
Centre d'Estudis Avancats de Blanes (CSIC)
Cami de Sta. Barbara s/n
17300 Blanes, Girona
Spain
FAX: 34 972 337806
Phone: 34 972 336101
WWW pages:
Institutional: http://www.ceab.csic.es
Personal: http://www.ceab.csic.es/~dani/
-- ANNELIDA
Discuss = annelida at net.bio.net = talk to all members
Server = biosci-server at net.bio.net = un/subscribes
Archives = http://www.bio.net/hypermail/annelida/
Resources = http://biodiversity.uno.edu/~worms/annelid.html
--
