new nsf policy

russell at DOGWOOD.BOTANY.UGA.EDU russell at DOGWOOD.BOTANY.UGA.EDU
Sat May 16 12:18:54 EST 1992


Newsgroups: bionet.genome.arabidopsis
Path: athena.cs.uga.edu!news
From: russell at dogwood.botany.uga.edu
Subject: New, Restrictive, NSF policy - "winning"
Message-ID: <1992May16.170807.10731 at athena.cs.uga.edu>
Sender: athena.cs.uga.edu
Organization: Botany Department, University of Georgia
Distribution: usa
Date: Sat, 16 May 1992 17:08:07 GMT


I'm appalled by the new NSF policy, and I'm also concerned about the
choice of terms used by Mary Clutter in defending this policy.
"winning"

The goals of the various funding agencies must be to support the
continuation of US Science, and, when there isn't enough money
to support all worthy science, to try to identify and support the
best science.

The new restriction of applications to only a single agency, in this
case NSF, manifestly makes the lives of biological scientists much
more difficult.  All biologists who have been funded a number of 
years have had the experience of having one agency rate a proposal
with excellents, and another place it below funding.  This is the
result of the luck of the draw in panel and external reviewers.

The restriction policy forces biologists into a form of gamesmanship
whereby one is forced to not only prepare the best proposal possible,
but one is also forced to calculate application strategies in a new
and painful way.

Why would any agency implement a strategy that is clearly a disservice
to the community it is supposed to be supporting?

One possible answer is that this is purely inter-agency politics.
Support for this lies in Dr. Clutter's use of the winning image.
Scientists and science are not winning as a result of this new
policy.  Proposal preparation and applications have suddenly become
much more difficult.
If NSF is somehow winning, it can only be doing so in the context
of winning something in an inter-agency political squabble, that
has lost sight of the overall goal of supporting the best research.

Russell Malmberg
russell at dogwood.botany.uga.edu



More information about the Arab-gen mailing list