Washington Post article (READ IT!)

an55614 at anon.penet.fi an55614 at anon.penet.fi
Fri Dec 10 04:19:27 EST 1993


> UNSPEAKABLE  CRIMES   This Story Can't Be Told in Canada. And So All Canada
> Is Talking About It..
> The Washington Post, November 23, 1993, FINAL Edition
> By: Anne Swardson, Washington Post Foreign Service
> Section: STYLE, p. b01
> Story Type: News Foreign
> Line Count: 214    Word Count: 2360
> 
> ST.  CATHARINES,  Ontario  -   Karla Homolka was resplendent on her wedding
> day,  June  29, 1991. Garlands of baby's breath adorned her hair and fluffy
> veil;  her  long  flounced  dress  made her look like Cinderella. Her proud
> husband  wore  white tie and tails. The couple left the church near Niagara
> Falls in a horse-drawn carriage.
> 
> About  20  miles  away  on  that  same sunny day, police were pulling seven
> blocks  of  concrete  out  of  the waters of a favorite local fishing spot.
> Encased  in  them  were  the  body parts of Leslie Mahaffy, a shy, delicate
> 14-year-old with long blond hair who had disappeared from a nearby town two
> weeks before.
> 
>    Only  two  people  in  Canada  knew  at  the time that those events were
> related, but nearly the entire population knows it now.
> 
>    Karla  Homolka,  23,  was sentenced last summer to 12 years in prison on
> two  counts  of  manslaughter  in  the deaths of Leslie Mahaffy and another
> teenage  girl.  Her  husband, Paul Teale, 29, awaits trial for their murder
> and other charges, including the rapes of 17 other women.
> 
>    But  the story of the most shocking set of crimes in Canada's history is
> even more ghoulish than those facts would indicate.
> 
>    Many  Canadians know the whole tale of evil, but they don't know it from
> reading  their  own newspapers or watching television.By judge's order, it
> is  illegal  in  this  country to disclose facts about the deaths of Leslie
> Mahaffy  and  15-year-old  Kristen French. And it is illegal to reveal that
> Homolka's  trial  showed  that  there  was  another victim: Karla Homolka's
> 14-year-old sister, Tammy, who died on Christmas Eve 1990.
> 
>    "This  case  is  unique  in  the  annals  of Canadian crime," says noted
> criminal  lawyer  Edward  L.  Greenspan,  who like many Canadians has heard
> "rumors"  about  it. "It involves such a marked departure from normal human
> conduct that we can't help being drawn to it."
>    The alleged perpetrators were attractive, well-dressed professionals who
> lived  in a high-rent neighborhood and had lots of friends. Yet the murders
> and  other  crimes they allegedly committed were particularly sadistic. The
> schoolgirl  victims  were abducted as they went about their daily routines,
> then  were  held prisoner while a variety of sexual tortures were performed
> on them. Some of those tortures were videotaped.
> 
>    The  Homolka-Teale  case "is the kind of homicide people are most afraid
> of,"  says  Anthony  Doob,  professor  of  criminology at the University of
> Toronto.  "It  involves  the abduction of children, which is every parent's
> worst  fear.  And  the  speculation is that the dimensions of the crime are
> extremely horrible."
> 
>    There  is  another  notable  element  to the case. One of the killers is
> female.  Karla  Homolka,  she  of the fairy-tale wedding dress, is expected
> later  to  testify against the husband from whom she has recently filed for
> divorce.  Whether  Homolka  was  herself  a  victim of her husband or was a
> deviant in her own right is not yet known. But what she did has shocked the
> few  who  have  been allowed in the courtroom at her trial and the many who
> have heard about it through other means.
> 
>    "She  was  a  participant  in  the  luring,  the confinement, the sexual
> activities  and  the  deaths," says a person familiar with what was said in
> the courtroom.
> 
>    The  case of Homolka and Teale has fascinated the nation, partly because
> the  crimes  the  couple  is  accused of are so horrible-and partly because
> obtaining  the facts of the case has itself become sport. Residents of this
> region  have  eagerly  and successfully sought the details through computer
> bulletin  boards, dinner-party gossip, stolen satellite television signals,
> secret  copies  of  a few articles in foreign publications-and even through
> eavesdropping on private conversations on commuter trains.
> 
>    The  full  story  of  Karla  Homolka and Paul Teale probably will not be
> known  until  after  his  trial,  but  much  of  it  was related in an airy
> courtroom  here  last July, when prosecutors read a long statement of facts
> agreed to by the defense as part of Homolka's plea bargain. The judge ruled
> that the information in the statement cannot be legally published in Canada
> until after Teale is tried.
> 
>    This account is based on interviews with people knowledgeable about what
> was said in the courtroom, and on press reports.
> 
>    Karla  Homolka  was 17 in 1987 when she met the man she would marry, who
> was  then  named Paul Bernardo. He was a university graduate, an accountant
> from  an  eastern  suburb  of  Toronto  that at the time was experiencing a
> series of violent rapes. She was a senior in high school in this industrial
> border  town,  a  quiet  girl  who  loved  animals.  The two quickly became
> infatuated;  he  moved  to  St. Catharines and she wrote in her high school
> yearbook that her wish was "to marry Paul and see him more than two times a
> week."
> 
>    Despite  his accounting training, Paul made his living in St. Catharines
> by  smuggling  tobacco  and  alcohol from New York into Canada, it has been
> reported.   After   graduating   from   high  school,  Karla  worked  as  a
> veterinarian's  assistant.  Later they moved into a pink clapboard Cape Cod
> on  the  shores  of Lake Ontario in a quiet neighborhood not far from where
> Homolka grew up.
> 
>    It is not clear at what point Homolka learned what kind of man her lover
> really  was.  But  even before Christmas of 1990, before they were married,
> she  was  helping  find girls for him for sex, according to accounts of the
> trial.  Friends  noticed,  according  to  press  reports,  that young girls
> visited  frequently, sometimes staying overnight. Some of them were said to
> be friends of Karla's younger sister, Tammy.
>    Tammy herself was to be Paul's Christmas present.
> 
>    According   to   accounts  of  the  trial,  Homolka  slipped  an  animal
> tranquilizer into Tammy's rum-and-eggnog on the evening of Dec. 23 in their
> parents'  house.  While  the young girl was unconscious, Teale had sex with
> her.  So  did  Karla. Each of them videotaped the other in the act. Karla's
> parents were at home, in another room, unaware.
> 
>    Then  Tammy  began  to  vomit.  Teale  and  Homolka carried her into her
> bedroom,  laid  her  in  bed,  then  called an ambulance. They did not tell
> medical personnel about the drug she had ingested. Tammy died the next day,
> Christmas Eve. The coroner ruled that she had choked on her own vomit.
> 
>    The  next  known victim was Leslie Mahaffy, from the town of Burlington.
> Teale  allegedly  abducted  her forcibly in June 1991, two weeks before his
> wedding,  and took her home in his car. The garage adjoins the house, and a
> tall fence blocks any view of the back yard from outside. Teale took Leslie
> inside  and locked himself in a room with her, according to accounts of the
> trial. Leslie lived two days at most before she died, of strangulation.
> 
>    Kristen  French  was  next,  10  months  later.  By this time, Teale had
> Homolka's  cooperation,  secured  with  the threat of revealing her role in
> Tammy's  death, Homolka said. Homolka helped him to abduct Kristen, a slim,
> brown-haired  figure skater of 15, on her way home from Catholic school one
> afternoon  in  April  1992.  Kristen  apparently  went over to the car in a
> church parking lot when Homolka, holding a map, asked for directions.
> 
>    Kristen's  nude  body  was  found  in  a  small  dump  about  two  weeks
> later-yards  from  the cemetery where Leslie Mahaffy is buried. Kristen had
> been  strangled  and her long hair cut off. Police later said she was alive
> until shortly before her body was found.
> 
>    During the time these crimes were being committed, relations between the
> young couple were deteriorating. Teale beat Homolka regularly and threw her
> down  the  stairs,  she  said.  Finally,  in  January  1993, he beat her so
> severely  with  a  flashlight  that she left home and went to the hospital.
> When  she  was  released,  she  went  to  her  parents'  house,  called the
> police-and started talking.
> 
>    About  this time her husband changed his name from Bernardo to Teale. He
> knew the police were looking for him.
> 
>    Paul  Teale  was  arrested  in  February  and  charged with 43 counts of
> sex-related  offenses  allegedly  committed  in Scarborough, his home town.
> Police  also  said he would be charged with the Mahaffy and French murders.
> About  that  time  the  investigation  into  the death of Tammy Homolka was
> reopened.  In  May,  Teale was charged with two counts of murder, of Leslie
> Mahaffy  and  Kristen  French,  as  well  as two counts each of kidnapping,
> forcible  confinement  and  aggravated  sexual  assault,  and  one count of
> committing an indignity to Leslie's body.
> 
>    Police  spent six weeks searching the Teale-Homolka house, removing more
> than  900  pieces  of evidence, some of them videotapes. It was revealed at
> the  trial  that  Kristen  had been shown a tape of Leslie. It is not known
> what  all  the other tapes showed, but indications are that to convict Paul
> Teale, prosecutors badly needed the testimony of his wife. In Canada, as in
> the  United  States,  one spouse cannot be compelled to testify against the
> other.
> 
>    By  the  time  Homolka's  manslaughter trial began, there was widespread
> speculation she would plead guilty in return for a reduced sentence.
> 
>    More  than  in  the United States, Canada chooses to muzzle the media in
> some  court  cases,  for  fear  that  open coverage could jeopardize a fair
> trial.  News  media are prohibited from reporting on any evidence presented
> at  a  bail  hearing  or  preliminary inquiry, for instance, until the full
> trial has begun. And judges have the prerogative, though it is rarely used,
> to restrict media coverage of a trial.
> 
>    In  the  Teale-Homolka case, prosecutors wanted to be sure that evidence
> presented  at  Homolka's  trial  did  not  taint the trial of her estranged
> husband,  which  will  not  take  place for at least 18 months. After legal
> arguments  back and forth-the media opposed a publication ban-Ontario Court
> Justice Francis Kovacs made his ruling.
> 
>    Canadian  reporters  could  be in the courtroom but could publish only a
> few prescribed facts, such as Karla Homolka's verdict and sentence (but not
> her  plea).  Foreign media were barred from the courtroom entirely because,
> the  judge  said,  the  ban could not be enforced against them. The general
> public  was  kept  out as well-Kovacs said he feared people would tell U.S.
> media what had happened. Buffalo media had been following the case closely;
> the  Buffalo  News and three network television affiliates were among those
> left outside the courtroom.
> 
>    At  Homolka's brief trial, prosecutor Murray Segal read the statement of
> facts,  a  25-minute litany of assault, rape and torture that left seasoned
> law  enforcement officers and journalists in tears. Virtually stumbling out
> of   the  courtroom,  reporters  called  what  they  heard  "gruesome"  and
> "devastating."  The  staid Toronto Globe and Mail said the next day that it
> was  "a  catalogue of depravity and death." Teale's lawyer, clearly shaken,
> took  his  glasses off and put his hand to his head whie the statement was
> being read.
> 
>    Two  others  addressed  the  court:  the  mothers  of Leslie Mahaffy and
> Kristen  French, who read statements about what their daughters' deaths had
> meant  to their families. Both women broke down several times on the stand,
> and  even  Karla  Homolka, who had remained impassive throughout the trial,
> was observed to be choking back tears and wiping her eyes.
> 
>    After  imposing  the  12-year  sentence  on  Homolka,  Kovacs  said, "No
> sentence  I  can  impose  would  adequately  reflect  the  revulsion of the
> community in the death of the young girls, who lived lives beyond reproach.
> I understand the outrage the community feels, and rightly so."
> 
>    Since that time, learning the secrets rvealed at the trial has become a
> cottage  industry,  particularly  in  Toronto,  about  60  miles from here.
> Compter  bulletin  boards  have sprung up that share facts and rumors. And
> though the publication ban allowed journalists to discuss what they learned
> only with their editors, newsrooms are rife with gossip.
>    The  law  enforcement  side  has  been  a source of stories as well. One
> observer  was  on  a  commuter train some time after the trial when a woman
> began  talking  to  a  friend.  The  woman  said she knew a law enforcement
> official  who  had  withdrawn from the case because he found the details so
> painful.  The  woman  then revealed those details, as the train fell silent
> and commuters craned their necks.
> 
>    "We've created a monster with this order," said one lawyer.
> 
>    A  few foreign news organizations, such as the Fox Television program "A
> Current  Affair,"  have  carried stories that included information from the
> trial, but only one Canadian publication, a satirical magazine, has printed
> prohibited   facts.   Canada's  constitution  includes  a  more  restricted
> definition of press freedom than does the U.S. Constitution, and editors of
> major  Canadian  newspapers and television networks say they do not believe
> in breaking the law. Their legal appeal of the ban is pending.
> 
>    A  British  newspaper printed a story that included banned material, and
> 1,000  copies  destined  to be sold in Toronto were voluntarily shredded by
> the distributor, after discussions with officials of the Ontario provincial
> government.  Similarly,  cable  systems  did  not  carry  the episode of "A
> Current Affair" that dealt with the Homolka case.
>    Some people believe the ban actually has been counterproductive. Nothing
> was  said  in  the  courtroom  about  the widespread rumors that Teale made
> "snuff  films"  and  sold them in nearby Buffalo, for instance, but reports
> persist,  in  part because there is no published truth to correct them. And
> then  there  is  the  question  of  whether  Homolka's sentence-she will be
> eligible  for  parole  in  four  years-was  appropriate  to the crime. That
> question  cannot  be  debated by the public because so much information has
> been withheld.
> 
>    "This  is  a  secret  trial of a major crime of monumental proportions,"
> said  Gordon  Domm, a retired police officer who on his own has distributed
> 50  videotapes of the "Current Affair" program to protest the ban. Domm was
> arrested  Friday  for  attempting  to  mail  out  200 copies of the British
> newspaper  article.  He  was  released,  the  articles were confiscated and
> police have not said whether he will be charged.
> 
>    Tammy  Homolka's  body  was  exhumed  a  few  weeks  after the trial and
> examined  by  government pathologists. So far no charges have been filed in
> her death, but the local coroner says the investigation is ongoing.
> 
>    Tammy has been reburied now. Her grave in a cemetery on the east side of
> St.  Catharines  is  planted  with  fresh  chrysanthemums. Her headstone is
> engraved  with  a  cross  and  a soccer ball. There is a little plasticized
> picture on it; she is smiling. The grave faces west, toward the house a few
> minutes'  walk  away  where  she  once  lived  with her parents and her big
> sister, Karla.
> 
> CAPTIONS:  Paul Teale, 29, has yet to be tried in the murder of two teenage
> girls.  His  wife,  Karla  Homolka,  23,  was  given 12 years in prison for
> manslaughter in a trial kept secret in Canada.
>    Two of the victims: Leslie Mahaffy, 14, left, and Kristen French, 15.
> 
> 
> -------------------------------------------------------------------------
> To find out more about the anon service, send mail to help at anon.penet.fi.
> Due to the double-blind, any mail replies to this message will be anonymized,
> and an anonymous id will be allocated automatically. You have been warned.
> Please report any problems, inappropriate use etc. to admin at anon.penet.fi.
> 


-------------------------------------------------------------------------
To find out more about the anon service, send mail to help at anon.penet.fi.
Due to the double-blind, any mail replies to this message will be anonymized,
and an anonymous id will be allocated automatically. You have been warned.
Please report any problems, inappropriate use etc. to admin at anon.penet.fi.



More information about the Bioforum mailing list