Birds do it (was: Cats pump rabbits/Soon we will all be Yoda)
claird at NeoSoft.com
Thu Jun 17 10:17:45 EST 1993
In article <1993Jun16.000525.13805 at iscsvax.uni.edu> klier at iscsvax.uni.edu writes:
>In article <1vl086$3je at umd5.umd.edu>, Bill Williams <bwilliam at oyster.smcm.edu> writes,
>referring to ring species and species definitions:
>> "As long as gene flow occurs between two populations, they belong to
>> the same species even if their members cannot breed together. For
>By this definition, most of the Orchidaceae, the largest family of
>flowering plants, becomes a single species...
>In truth, there doesn't seem to be a simple definition of species
>appropriate to all groups of organisms -- the best I'm able
>to come up with, is "A species is a group delineated a competent taxonomist
>familiar with the organisms in question." (yes, tongue in cheek).
Kay is, of course, quite right in pointing out to what extent
some of the other kingdoms mock our zoo-centric "definitions".
My proposal is that we give up on (well, at least postpone for
a bit) definition-hunting, and pursue the study of particular
cases. One that caught my eye recently is
Parsons, Thomas J., Storrs L. Olson, and
Michael J. Braun
1993 "Unidirectional Spread of Secondary
Plumage Traits Across an Avian Hy-
brid Zone", Science, volume 260,
pages 1643-1646 (11 June 1993)
As the abstract summarizes, "Theory predicts that traits under
positive selection can rapidly cross a hybrid zone in spite of
a substantial barrier to neutral gene flow between hybridizing
taxa. An avian hybrid zone ... is reported here that displays
an unusual patter of noncoincident clines. ... [S]exual sel-
ection is driving male sexual traits across the zone." I wish
I could come up with something novel, but sexual selection
continues to be, as a number of senior biologists have publicly
opined, the big story we need to understand.
I've adjusted follow-ups a bit.
claird at Neosoft.com (claird%Neosoft.com at uunet.uu.net) +1 713 267 7966
claird at litwin.com (claird%litwin.com at uunet.uu.net) +1 713 996 8546
More information about the Bioforum