Stop Dr. Bob

U27111 at U27111 at
Sun Jan 14 05:00:08 EST 1996

Hey George,

It's nice to see you over here for a change?

you wrote on Sat, 13 Jan 1996 15:52:28 GMT:

>I think it is a sin that Bob Gallo is getting millions for a lab
>to share with that other fraud, Bob Redfield.

George, over here were tend not to come out and say such things
directly.  Too blunt of a language for the delicate eyes of those
who read here.  :)

We need to first beat around the bush a bit, build an argument, and
then when people continue to disagree for a while... then do our
name calling.

This is a more proper scientific discussion etiquette. :)

>What about Gallo's work with SP-PG for KS in mice?  It hasn't been
>reproduced and I know people who wanted this angiogenesis
>inhibitor to heal their KS. Because of his sloppy, if not outright
>fraudulent, work, people suffered horribly.  This IS a sin.

Are you referring to people who actually tried the drug and still
died (suffering yet more from possible side-effects from the drug)?

Or, are you saying that people put high hopes on this drug... only
to be disappointed when the Witte/Gallo debates resulted in the
drug from being pulled from further human study?

???  I just want to be clear on the intent of this statement.

For it was my understanding that only a few human subjects were
actually tested with SP-PG?

>And how can we possibly believe his latest research on the
>macrophage inflammatory proteins (MIP) and RANTES role in HIV
>suppression?  (I mean, the article on its own is hardly convincing

Why do you say that?

Exactly why isn't it convincing?

Otherwise, are you are just stating a personal opinion?

>And Redfield?  Lying about a 5th-rate envelope's vaccine's effect
>on viral load?

??? I don't know what you are referring to here.  Remember, this
isn't an AIDS NG... we haven't been discussing these specific
details on Redfield's questionable vaccine study.

>I apologize if this is repetitive--I'm jumping in the middle and,
>as is apparent, I am rather shy and retiring about my opinions!!

No... some of this actually isn't repetitive in here.

And you shy?  Couldn't tell it by me.


More information about the Bioforum mailing list