Open rough draft for forming a RC advocacy group.....
arthures at magpage.com
Fri Jan 19 02:10:13 EST 2001
On Fri, 19 Jan 2001, Josh Halpern wrote:
> rmchamberlin at my-deja.com wrote:
> > Normally I don't respond to Art's flamebaiting, but I'm feeling generous
> > today, so:
> > In article <946u2g$itk$0 at 184.108.40.206>,
> > Arthur Sowers <arthures at magpage.com> wrote:
> > > Then, we have
> > > all those who are in nice, cushy situations and essentially say to
> > > themselves "I've got mine, I'm not going to help anyone else" or "I've got
> > > mine, I don't want anything to change that migh affect 'mine'." People
> > > like Becky and Josh seem to be totally uninterested in the health of the
> > > PhD culture and I don't recall hearing either of them complain much about
> > > their own situations and hardly if any complaints about the PhD culture,
> > > itself, either.
> > You're right, I don't make a career of using the internet to "help"
> > people I don't know personally and whose circumstances I can't fully
> > understand. I personally don't believe that one-size-fits-all advice is
> > as valuable as one-on-one interaction (i.e. "mentoring"), which is why I
> > put more energy into promoting the careers of the people around me than
> > those on src. You, Art, cannot possibly know what I do outside of src,
> > and I'll thank you to refrain from making assumptions.
> Let me sign on to that.
> Art is trying in his usual way to bully us. We have always
> cut him a great deal of slack,
Never. The criticism and snobery from you were there from the start.
poor Art he got fired. Shed a tear
> we did.
That was never true, either.
But Art is a great one for telling others how to live their
> lives, just don't be happier or more successful than Art.
It must be nice to not care about anyone but yourself.
> Of course, what Art means by the "Ph.D. culture" is really the
> losers who stand in the corner with him and moan about how
> unfair life and their advisor is.
As if the rest of the world is already perfect, isn't it?
Anyone who succeeds, or picks
> himself up after a setback and goes on, or tries something new
> has no interest in hanging with the self-destructive.
Anyone who succeeds usually, I see, just looks out for himself and gives
himself credit instead of nice situations that were already there for
> The idea he is pushing now is obviously a response to Dereck's
> initiative in creating a FAQ.
My how you can jump to conclusions.
This will be amusing. I await the
> blurt of trumpets.
Here I agree, but I've already heard the trumpets.... all off key.
> josh halpern
Arthur E. Sowers, PhD
| Science career information website: |
| http://www.magpage.com/~arthures |
More information about the Bioforum