RESULT: sci.med.surgery.plastic fails 85:21

Bill Aten bill at netagw.com
Sat Mar 23 00:01:44 EST 1996


                                RESULT
        unmoderated group sci.med.surgery.plastic fails 85:21

Voting closed at 23:59:59 UTC, 22 Mar 1996.

This vote was conducted by a neutral third party.  Questions about the
proposed group should be directed to the proponent.

Proponent: Steve Darnaud <hvpsbd at hofstra.edu>
Mentor:    Chris Stone   <cbstone at phoenix.princeton.edu>
Votetaker: Bill Aten <bill at netagw.com>

There were 106 valid votes submitted during the voting period.  Each proposed
newsgroup, in order to pass, must have at least 2/3 YES votes and at least
100 more YES than NO votes.  The results are as follows:

sci.med.surgery.plastic results - 106 valid votes

 Yes   No : 2/3? >100? : Pass? : Group
---- ---- : ---- ----- : ----- : -------------------------------------------
  85   21 :  Yes    No :    No : sci.med.surgery.plastic
   2 abstaining votes

The proposal failed.

There is a five day discussion period after these results are posted.
Unless serious and significant allegations of voting irregularities are
raised, the proposal may not be voted on again for six months.

The remainder of the RESULT contains:
   Newsgroups Line
   Rationale
   Charter
   Final Voting Acknowledgements

NEWSGROUPS LINE:
sci.med.surgery.plastic	Plastic and reconstructive surgery.

RATIONALE: sci.med.surgery.plastic

Although there are mailing lists and other sci.med newsgroups which
address different aspects of the medical profession, there is no
usenet-based newsgroup to discuss plastic surgery.

CHARTER: sci.med.surgery.plastic

Sci.med.surgery.plastic is intended to be an unmoderated arena for
discussions relevant to plastic and reconstructive surgery.

This group is created to provide a forum for information, ideas, issues,
and experiences regarding plastic and reconstructive surgery.
Sci.med.surgery.plastic is designed for professionals as well as lay
people, and is anticipated to have a broad interest.

Topics for discussion include, but are not limited to:

 - Argon, carbon-dioxide, and copper vapor laser
 - Hemangiomas, vascular malformations, and other birthmarks
 - Procedures, innovations and results in endoscopic, microvascular,
   and other reconstructive surgeries
 - Scars, skin-grafts, breast-implants, etc.
 - Dermabrasion and cryosurgery
 - Cleft lip and palate, craniofacial synostosis and microsomia
 - Other multi-disciplinary sectors - Dermatology, Hematology, and
   Ophthalmology

END CHARTER.

FINAL VOTING ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS:

sci.med.surgery.plastic Final Vote Ack


                                                  sci.med.surgery.plastic ---+
                                                                             |
101463.103 at compuserve.com                                         e. hartman N
76357.1262 at compuserve.com                                     Patrick Hudson Y
aa742 at freenet.Buffalo.EDU                                  Rosemarie Ventura Y
acram at dsurgery.surgery.uiowa.edu                              Albert E. Cram Y
ade at freddiek.demon.co.uk                                     adrian richards Y
admpt at hrp.health.ufl.edu                                        Danny Martin Y
alex at uniito.e-burg.su                                 Alexander N. Chelnokov Y
andsue at atlas.co.uk                                            Loshan Kangesu Y
Barzfam712 at aol.com                               Joan Barzilai, R.N., M.S.N. Y
birchall at email.njin.net                                                 Shag N
booda at datasync.com                                           Martin H. Booda N
bresnab at tiac.net                                             Brian Bresnahan N
brian.hillis at ablelink.org                                       Brian Hillis Y
cae1 at aol.com                                              Christine A. Evers Y
catseye at netcom.com                                            Mark Kupferman Y
cbstone at phoenix.Princeton.EDU                                    Chris Stone Y
ccchen at math.ccu.edu.tw                                      Chiun-Chuan Chen Y
chicago at ix.netcom.com                                        Brad Hennenfent Y
cls48 at columbia.edu                                             Chris Stamper Y
COMPRG at vaxc.hofstra.edu                                 Dr. Peter R. Gershon Y
COMSRB at vaxc.hofstra.edu                                         Stewart Bird Y
cyberida at mail.channel.co.uk                                     JUSTIN KIRBY Y
dan at widomaker.com                                             Dan Harrington Y
davidj at knoware.nl                                               David Jairth N
ddowney at u.washington.edu                                       Daniel Downey Y
donkiely at polarnet.com                                              Don Kiely Y
douglas at netdoor.com                                        Douglas L Stewart Y
dsc at xray.hmc.psu.edu                                        David S. Channin Y
efs at summa4.mv.com                                                Ed Sinamark Y
ejnoomen at xs4all.nl                                           Eric-Jan Noomen Y
ffossa at postoffice.ptd.net                                       Stacey Fossa Y
finn at nasw.org                                                    Robert Finn Y
fnord at odyssee.net                                                Thomas Moll Y
frensillis at bah.com                                       Stephanie Frensilli Y
greg at intellinet.com                                               Greg Eanes Y
gwittwer at access.ch                                                   wittwer Y
Helsav at aol.com                                                  Helena Savin Y
hmueller at maxsolns.com                                          Harry Mueller Y
HSilver2 at aol.com                                          Harold Silverstein Y
HVPJJV at vaxc.hofstra.edu                                    Joseph J. Valerio Y
HVPJPK at vaxc.hofstra.edu                                            John Kopp Y
HVPSBD at vaxc.hofstra.edu                                        Steve Darnaud Y
HVPTRF at vaxc.hofstra.edu                                       Timothy Fehmel Y
I.G.Camilleri at newcastle.ac.uk                                 Ivan Camilleri Y
ilana at ncar.ucar.edu                                              Ilana Stern Y
ivheij at IAEhv.nl                                          Ivar van Heijningen N
jab3 at ix.netcom.com                                             Julie Brumley Y
jai at mantra.com                                                   Jai Maharaj Y
jasblair at easynet.co.uk                                           James Blair Y
Jeffleader at aol.com                                         Jeffery J. Leader N
jonathan at e-mail.com                                        Jonathan Richards Y
kim at shell.portal.com                                            Kim DeVaughn Y
kirby at trams.co.uk                                                 Hugo Kirby Y
Krin135 at aol.com                                    Charles S. Krin, DO FAAFP Y
lucian at dircon.co.uk                                               Lucian Ion Y
Marita2000 at aol.com                                        Marita Silverstein Y
med30065 at leonis.nus.sg                                           Tan Min-Han Y
mich at ipoint.vlsi.uiuc.edu                                  Michelle Lockwood Y
mis at thetics.europa.com                                    Harold Eisenman MD Y
ml3e+ at andrew.cmu.edu                                          Michael Loomis N
mmt at RedBrick.COM                                               M Mike Taksar -
morgan3 at ix.netcom.com                                           Allan Morgan Y
mrack at blue.weeg.uiowa.edu                                       Michael Rack Y
naera at lightbulb.com                                                Naera Kim Y
nick at inferno.fc.hp.com                                        Nick Ingegneri Y
NICKNACKR at popalex1.linknet.net                         FORREST NICK ROBINSON Y
olav at viking.mv.com                                           Olav Nieuwejaar N
patl at catfish.lcs.mit.edu                                 Patrick J. LoPresti N
paxil at interlog.com                                            Trevor Tymchuk Y
pgoedhar at xs4all.nl                                         Peter T. Goedhart N
phoebeuc at garnet.berkeley.edu                                     Fu-Mei Chen Y
phublou at innet.be                                              Patrick Hublou Y
piers at channel.co.uk                                      Piers Hogarth-Scott Y
prnmom at AZStarNet.com                                             Jane Porter Y
Rbtlwlss at gnn.com                                             Robert  Lawless Y
repstein at BIOMED.MED.YALE.EDU                              Richard W. Epstein Y
rhinks at herbie.unl.edu                                        Rebecca R Hinks Y
rick at bcm.tmc.edu                                              Richard Miller N
roberto at hsc.fr.net                                           Ollivier Robert Y
ryang at gwis2.circ.gwu.edu                                             G. Ryan N
rzuw039 at rz.uni-wuerzburg.de                                  Juergen Weinelt N
SamOgbeide at aol.com                                               Sam Ogbeide Y
Sands_Lynne at mm.rdd.lmsc.lockheed.com                             Lynne Sands Y
schultd at indirect.com                                          Daniel Schultz Y
sdonovan at ix.netcom.com                                        Sheila Donovan Y
SFX at appl2.hrz.uni-siegen.de                                  Lars Eilebrecht -
sgc at mars.superlink.net                                           Stan Cooper Y
sjohnson at mprgate.mpr.ca                                        Susan Johnson Y
SLYRICH at aol.com                                              Sylvia Richards Y
smarry at turing.toronto.edu                                       Smarasderagd N
Spooner at aol.com                                                 Andy Spooner Y
stainles at bga.com                                                Dwight Brown N
stevel at ucla.edu                                             Stephen Lessnick N
SWagleD at gnn.com                                                   Sean Wagle Y
swhite at interaccess.com                                           Steve White Y
tgm at netcom.com                                          Thomas G. McWilliams Y
tgriff at ix.netcom.com                                             Tom Griffin Y
thirion at verilog.fr                                              Marc Thirion N
thor.kottelin at pcb.mpoli.fi                                     Thor Kottelin Y
tlawson at garamond.univpubs.american.edu                        Todd C. Lawson N
TSTTM at OFFICE.HOFSTRA.EDU                                       Theresa Macri Y
UGM3AA at leeds.ac.uk                                           Plastic surgeon Y
widenius at cc.helsinki.fi                                       Risto Widenius N
Wijthoff at ext.eur.nl                                                 Wijthoff N
xanthian at qualcomm.com                                        Kent Paul Dolan Y
zafaran at super.zippo.com                                     Patricia A. Swan Y
zelda at teleport.com                                          Eileen J. Phelan Y
zippy at leland.Stanford.EDU                                Christopher T. Shen Y



More information about the Bionews mailing list