IUBio Biosequences .. Software .. Molbio soft .. Network News .. FTP

Antiaging Research Priorities [was Re: Major Criticisms of

Steven B. Harris sbharris at ix.netcom.com
Sat Sep 19 00:42:03 EST 1998


In <_ECM1.5962$c3.10789481 at tor-nn1.netcom.ca> "David Lloyd-Jones"
<dlj at pobox.com> writes: 
>
>On calorie restriction:
>
>I think it is hilarious, and very American, that one of the Toms
(TomLEF?)
>suggested studying CR so that its essence could be discovered and then
>perhaps injected into or fed to the population at large. Why not just
>restrict calories?

   A trick question?  Duh, because it causes many people to be hungry
all the time, which is best annoying and at worst is a sort of
suffering which removes a lot of the joy in life. 


>
>On mice:
>
>The other guy (TomExcelife??) cannot write a parsable sentence, which
is
>part of his problem. Another part is his notion that ice in the wild
live a
>long time. Fact is they normally get picked off by voles, hawks, dogs
and
>cats. Microbes. McCormick Harvesters.


  Fact is they live about 6 months on average, due to the above.  Not a
long time.


>This same guy thinks that the French lady who lived to 121++ was in
nature
>in some way.  Does he think she spent her last fifty years without
>antibiotics? Hell, her whole life was post-Pasteur.

  Yep.  On the othe rhand, so is good record keeping on a population
basis.  For example, we don't know for sure the birth year of so recent
a historical figure as Doc Holladay (to treat the first example which
comes to mind).  His only birth record was a victim of one of Sherman's
raids in Georgia.  That's the way the world was, not so long ago.



                                          Steve Harris



More information about the Cellbiol mailing list

Send comments to us at biosci-help [At] net.bio.net