Something unknowable in immunology? Simple logic?

Shiv A. Prasad shiv at hiv.med.umn.edu
Thu Jan 20 20:54:25 EST 1994


In article <2hn1ui$m72 at netnews.upenn.edu> dfonseca at mail.sas.upenn.edu (Dina Fonseca) writes:
>
>I can see that the rate of antigen experience by T cells is 
>greatest when younger, but this ignores the fact that new TcR and Ig
>are generated right up until the day you die.  Since antigen receptor
^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^
> generation is essentially a random process it is inevitable
>that cells with self-reactive receptors will emerge from the bone marrow
> all throughout life. If the thymus involutes after
>puberty, where are all these new cells getting their education
> (both in +ve and -ve selection)?
>
>Is this really a problem? If the thymus involutes, then 
>no T cells will be made i.e. no positive selection.
>As no T cells are made, it does'nt matter that there
^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^
>is no negative selection either.
>

The underscored statements seem contradictory.  Experiments with adult thymec-
tomized mice, adult bone marrow chimeras, and sublethal radiation of adult
mice suggest that involution of the thymus does not render it non-functional.

--
Shiv A. Prasad				shiv at lenti.med.umn.edu
Dept. of Microbiology			pras0005 at student.tc.umn.edu
Univ. of Minnesota




More information about the Immuno mailing list