Anonynimity in the review process (was Authors' rights)

Duane F Marble dmarble at magnus.acs.ohio-state.edu
Thu Dec 24 08:28:37 EST 1992


For many years a University of Chicago journal (Current Anthropology)
has made a point of requesting public comment ("reviews") of articles
that were subject to a variety of opinions. This was done with the
author's approval and the article was held for two or three issues in
order to allow copies to be mailed to all readers who requested them
and to allow their short comments to be returned to the editors. These
public replies were then published in conjunction with the original
article and a summary comment by the author. This "star" treatment is
not done for all articles, but I have felt this was an excellent idea.
-- 
Duane F. Marble			       E-mail: dmarble at magnus.acs.osu.edu
Department of Geography                Telephone: (614) 292-2250
The Ohio State University
Columbus, Ohio 43210                   Fax: (614) 292-6213



More information about the Jrnlnote mailing list