nash at biologysx.lan.nrc.ca
Thu Jun 10 20:41:22 EST 1993
In article <C8F77F.MzA at news2.cis.umn.edu> horton at molbio.cbs.umn.edu (Robert Horton) writes:
>From: horton at molbio.cbs.umn.edu (Robert Horton)
>Subject: Ethidium Bromide
>Date: Thu, 10 Jun 1993 19:18:57 GMT
>Subject: Re: Ethidium Bromide mutagenesis
>References: <1993May6.145845.42883 at urz.unibas.ch>
>X-Newsreader: Tin 1.1 PL5
>bickle at urz.unibas.ch wrote:
>: Since this (very thin) thread started, I've done a little reading in the
>: subject. It turns out that EtBr is not mutagenic in the Ames test unless
>: it is S100 activated, when it scores just above background.
>So why all of the paranoia about EtBr? In our lab, we've ended up collecting
>the stuff in jugs until the "to bleach or not to bleach" question is finally
>settled. Is it really that dangerous? The Merck index lists its therapeutic
>cat (vet) as an antihelminthic in sheep ("Mary had a little lamb/ Whose fleece
>was orange and glowed...") but the way people treat it, you'd think it was
>(gasp!) radioactive or somethin'. If they've been feeding it to sheep for
>years in quantities large enough to kill worms, you'd think somebody would
>actually KNOW if it causes leukemia or not by now. I haven't been able to find
>much in the biomed literature (ok, I didn't look REAL hard); any NetWisdom
>would be appreciated.
I always figured ethidium bromide was over-rated as a hazard, but being the
cautious type, and _not-an-expert_, always erred on the side of not
splashing it on my colleagues.
What I do remember was an experiment we did in 2nd year biochem, wa-a-ay
back in 197-umph!. We looked at the ability of ethidium bromide to: a)
cause petite mutations in yeast, and b) revert a tyr mutation to wild type
(also in yeast). It did the former very well, but not the latter at all.
On the other hand, EMS did b) very well indeed. So, if your DNA is not
naked, maybe you don't have to worry as much????
John Nash | Email: Nash at biologysx.lan.nrc.ca.
Institute for Biological Sciences |
National Research Council of Canada | Email to my other NRC accounts
Ottawa, Ontario, Canada. | is usually forwarded here.
*** Disclaimer: All opinions are mine, not NRC's! ***
More information about the Methods