braam at DINGO.RICE.EDU
braam at DINGO.RICE.EDU
Tue Mar 30 05:50:19 EST 1993
Most people suggest using Amersham-ECL for chemiluminescent westerns.
Note that all replies were positive; there were no "worst" kits
1. "I have not done any extensive comparisons of systems available for
chemiluminescent westerns, but I have been using the ECL system from
with horseradish peroxidase as the secondary antibody) with very clean
Of course, background will increase if the membrane is not properly
if excessively high amounts of antibody are used (probably because it is
washed off well.)
Good luck, Estelle Hrabak"
2." I never used the kit myself (I usually work with DNA, not protein) but
of my labmates have tried the Amersham chemiluminescence kit and loved it.
It is extremely easy, reliable, sensative, and quantitave (or at least they
tell me). In general, I have been very happy with Amersham quality and
service, and I have a lot of confidence in their stuff.
Dr. Leonard N. Bloksberg
PreissJ at clvax1.cl.msu.edu
Dept. of Biochemistry
Michigan State University"
3. "I have used Amersham's ECL kit with success for quite a while. It
appears to be quantitative across a wide range, probably limited by the
film you use.
Kodak AR or S appears to work quite well, Amersham do their own film for
but I've never felt the need to buy it! I transfer onto Hybond-C,
also from Amersham. Standard disclaimers....
R. P. Grant <>< rpgrant at molbiol.ox.ac.uk
Sir William Dunn School of Pathology Fax. +44 865 275556
University of Oxford, UK. Tel. +44 865 275565"
4." Our group is currently using Amersham's ECL Western blotting
kit and we are satisfied with it. We get nice quantitative
bands from westerns and the chemiluminescence reaction lasts
for minutes, giving ample time for multiple exposures (usually
3 seconds is enough!). You have to wash filters carefully
before adding the substrate, otherwise the background glow may
give you nice black films.
Hope this helps.
National Public Health Institute
"I highly recommend "Western-Light" by Tropix, Inc, Bedford, MA
(800) 542-2369. The sensitivity of the reagent allowed
me to detect fairly quantitatively a low level of expression
from the E. coli chromosome. Combined with a PVDF membrane
(Immobilon from Millipore) it was super. However, I did not
use the secondary Ab that came with the kit as it gave a
cross-reacting band with my antibody. So I used the AP
conjugated Ab from Promega that I had used with the color
Needless to say I have no affiliation with the
above companies, except that the people at Tropix were
very helpful and I have a vested interest in keeping
them in business.
Boston University School of Medicine
pfoster at med-itvax1.bu.edu"
"Boehringer, without a doubt - but if you can conjugate your own Ab with
alkaline phosphatase, and buy AMPPD cheaper than from B-M (eg. from
Tropix, in New Bedford), then you can make your own kit for cheap. "
| Ed Rybicki, PhD | "Emancipate yourselves from |
| (ed at micro.uct.ac.za) | mental slavery |
| Dept Microbiology | None but ourselves |
| University of Cape Town | Can free our minds...." |
| Private Bag, Rondebosch | |
| 7700, South Africa | - Bob Marley |
| fax: 27-21-650 4023 | (Redemption Songs) |
More information about the Methods