RNase Protection Assay; non-specific?

Rolands G. Aravindan aravind at wsunix.wsu.edu
Sat Feb 21 00:53:16 EST 1998

Hello friends,

I have never actually done RPA, but a Professor in the department showed
me a RPA blot that had just returned from a journal after initial
review.The reviewer's criticism of the blot was rather strange to me. I
wonderhow one could explain/rebutt it.

Let me explain the blot, in short. It is rather clean with clearly
treatment-dose-dependent increase in the expression of POMC mRNA and the
standard was constant. Both signals are remarkably strong and the
background is remarkably white and clean; except for another minor
(about1/100 the specific band) band, also appearing dose-dependent, about
100 bases lesser in size. Considering the strength of the specific signal,
the blot could have been sent in with slightly decreased exposure to film
without compromising authenicity (?; wrong? coments appreciated) in the
first place.

Strangely, the reviewer has asked "whether the minor POMC band was also
scanned"! Being quite familiar with Northerns and the like, I would have
thought that there really is no confusion as to the fact that the minor
band is not related to POMC and that it really is nonspecific. Or am I
wrong? Anybody out there have any suggestions as to how one could
explain/rebutt the reviewer's comment?

I would be very grateful for all replies, either directly or via the NG.

Thanks in advance,


aravind at vetmed.wsu.edu

More information about the Methods mailing list