toby at carson.u.washington.edu
Thu Nov 5 12:03:53 EST 1992
In article <1992Nov3.183314.7159 at mcclb0.med.nyu.edu> deustachio at mcclb0.med.nyu.edu writes:
>Nigel Walker asked:
>> What is a Kosambi centimorgan? How does it differ from a plain vanilla
>> centimorgan? Is there a difference?
>and Joe Felsenstein replied:
>> I think a Kosambi centimorgan is just a name for an ordinary centimorgan,
>> when that centimorgan is estimated from recombination fractions, using
>> the mapping function of Kosambi:
>> Kosambi, D. D. 1944. The estimation of map distance from recombination
>> values. Annals of Eugenics 12: 172-175.
>> There are other mapping functions, and there is no real reason to append the
>> name of the mapping function to the name "centimorgan" as if what it
>> calculates is incommensurable with ordinary centimorgans.
>It's not quite that simple. Mapping functions embody theories about inter-
>ference (interactions - positive or negative - among a given number of
>progeny chromosomes into a 'true' (contingent on the validity of your theory)
>map distance. Different mapping functions make quite different assumptions
>in this respect and, especially for low density maps (i.e., recombination
>fractions greater than 10% between adjacent markers), yield appreciably
>different results. At the same time, all the mapping functions I know of
>converge as the distance between adjacent markers gets small.
>NYU Medical Center - Biochemistry
>peter at mcbcm2.med.nyu.edu
I'm guessing that the creator of the "Felsenstein mapping function"
(Felsenstein  A mathematically tractable family of of genetic
mapping functions with different amounts of interference. Genetics
91:769-775) is pretty well aware of the theory and practice of
genetic mapping, and of the underlying assumptions. I think Joe's
point is that all of the mapping functions give the "true" map
distance if their assumptions are met; proving that the assumptions
are (or are not) met is the problem.
Department of Biochemistry and College of Forest Resources
University of Washington, Seattle
toby at u.washington.edu
More information about the Mol-evol