Treeing partial sequences

Ed Rybicki ED at
Wed Mar 10 02:14:51 EST 1993

> From:          mkkuhner at (Mary K. Kuhner)
> In article <1993Mar8.190355.21445 at> robison1 at (Keith Robison) writes:
> >I would like to make a tree for a gene family, but the problem is that
> >robison at
> Two possible ideas (I certainly won't claim to know the best way):
> 1.  Use a distance method such as neighbor-joining, and calculate
> 2.  Make a number of subtrees (using whatever method you would normally
> In either case, the resulting phylogeny should not be taken very
> seriously, as in my experience there is not enough information in a gene
> fragment to make a good phylogeny estimate.  At best it's a rough
> sketch.

I would argue with the above statement (...not enough info...): this
should perhaps read "...not NECESSARILY enough info...".  In my experience
with plant viruses, I get very much the same results, with the
geminiviruses, with 254 bp compared to what I get with 2700 bp (whole
genome) - same with potyviruses; CP gives same phylogeny as whole genome
same as 3' untranslated region.

Remember, he said A DECENT IDEA (or words to same effect) - and using
something like CLUSTALV or PileUp on a mixture of whole and partial
sequences appears to work quite well, as the relationships you get are
those between comparable areas of the sequences (personal experience:
comparing whole single picornavirus polyproteins with putative picornaviral
equivalents and 2-part proteins from two groups of plant viruses, worked

 | Ed Rybicki, PhD             |     "Emancipate yourselves from      |
 | (ed at        |            mental slavery            |
 | Dept Microbiology           |          None but ourselves          |
 | University of Cape Town     |         Can free our minds...."      |
 | Private Bag, Rondebosch     |                                      |
 | 7700, South Africa          |             - Bob Marley             |
 | fax: 27-21-650 4023         |          (Redemption Songs)          |

More information about the Mol-evol mailing list