Mushrooms in a painting
e.hutton at ic.ac.uk
Mon Feb 12 11:11:31 EST 2001
Nathan Wilson wrote:
> It actually looks to me like there might be more than one species
> involved. The one where you can see the underside the best looks like it
> was probably white spored. For that one I lean towards Gymnopus but the
> gills are unusually shallow.
I haven't heard of Gymnopus. Do you mean Gymnopilus? (which in any case
has rusty spores).
> If you look at the larger one with the
> broken stem it looks like it had a dark spore print. That one suggests a
> Hypholoma to me.
The large upsidedown one seems to have black spores and could possibly
be a woodland Agaricus (e.g. Sylvaticus) with the ring not noticed
by the artist. There are traces of black spore print on one of the
The white spored ones could also be Collybia Dryophila, as pointed
out to me by Paul Pirot by e-mail. The habitat is certainly better
for this than for Mycena Galericulata.
Someone really ought to go and look at the original painting.
> On Fri, 9 Feb 2001, Edwin Hutton wrote:
> > Moselio Schaechter wrote:
> > >
> > > The following website:
> > > http://www.nationalgallery.org.uk/cgi-bin/WebObjects.dll/CollectionPublisher
> > > .woa/wa/work?workNumber=NG1222
> > > shows a painting in the National Gallery, London, by the Dutch artist
> > > Melchior d'Hondecoeter with mushrooms in it.
> > >
> > > The painting (1668) is titled "Birds and Butterflies among Plants."
> > > The mushrooms in the right foreground look collybioid, but that's as far as
> > > I can get in identification. What do you think they might be?
> > >
> > > Make sure to click the picture, to see it at the highest magnification.
> > >
> > > Elio Schaechter
> > They look a bit like a Mycena, possibly M. Galericulata due to the size.
> > However we can't get a magnifier to them to be at all sure,
> > and they look a bit old. Fortunately the painter has adopted a
> > photographic style.
> > Edwin Hutton
More information about the Mycology