alert versus aware

Martin Knopman mknopman at
Wed Sep 29 08:50:51 EST 1999

Alex Morgan wrote in message <37F1CFD0.6C47 at>...
>'mind' means something like - to borrow your phrase
>- 'the seat of consciousness, thought, volition, and feeling', whereas
>'soul' means something like 'an incorporeal, eternal mentality'.  While
>these words might mean different things to different people, only the
>latter has a metaphysical commitment 'built-in' BY VIRTUE OF IT'S

That's ridiculous.  As soon as you mention volition you are out of the
physical, as much as any explanation of soul would take you.

Martin Knopman

More information about the Neur-sci mailing list