IUBio Biosequences .. Software .. Molbio soft .. Network News .. FTP

Deities cannot exist because of their consciousness

Wolf Kirchmeir wwolfkir at sympatico.can
Thu Nov 27 15:50:26 EST 2003


On Thu, 27 Nov 2003 18:17:18 GMT, Dio wrote:

>Excuse me,
>
>Would you mind to say if those premises are false?
>Never mind about my conclusion, you said that my premises are false.
>
>Please, demonstre that: you are welcome!!
>
>Regards

As I've said before, their truth or falsehood irrelevant. But just to be nice
to you, I'll give you my opinions: #1 is true, I suppose, since  God says
"I". #2 may be true for consciousness when referring to material beings, if
you mean "material brain" for "brain." But it is false when referring to
immaterial beings, since immaterial, conscious beings don't have a material
brain, and God or "god" is by definition non-material.

Not that it matters, since you argument is invalid. Your argument is invalid
because you using a proposition about material entities to argue about the
existence of non-material entities, which is the error of _confounding
categories_. You might as well claim the "god" does not exist because rocks
do exist. As I said before, go take a course in logic.

If your next post illustrates some understanding of what I've said, I may
decide to continue your education. Otherwise, goodbye.

-- 
Wolf Kirchmeir, Blind River ON Canada
"Nature does not deal in rewards or punishments, but only in consequences."
(Robert Ingersoll)






More information about the Neur-sci mailing list

Send comments to us at biosci-help [At] net.bio.net