[Neuroscience] Re: Combine neuroscience and computer science
(by jalegris from sympatico.ca)
Wed Jan 28 10:36:57 EST 2009
On Jan 28, 7:22 am, KATHARINE LEAH DICKSON <kldick... from wisc.edu> wrote:
> Studying consciousness in neuroscience, I think, requires a knowledge of what consciousness actually is. It's not impossible to study it - Giulio Tononi at my institution is doing some research related to sleep, and I think Tristan Bekinschtein at Cambridge is doing research on 'disorders of consciousness', but I don't know how you'd approach it from computational paths since much of 'consciousness' is colored by human emotions, which computers cannot simulate.
> Katharine Leah Dickson
> kldick... from wisc.edu
> ----- Original Message -----
> From: "J.A.Legris" <jaleg... from sympatico.ca>
> Date: Tuesday, January 27, 2009 11:35 am
> Subject: [Neuroscience] Re: Combine neuroscience and computer science
> To: neur-... from magpie.bio.indiana.edu
> > On Jan 26, 8:33 am, davide <davide... from REMOVECAPITALhotmail.com> wrote:
> > > Hello everybody,
> > > I explain a bit the strange subject. By the way I am not sure this
> > is
> > > the right NG, apologies if it isn't.
> > > I have studied computer science for many years and very recently
> > > robotics but now for some reasons (I am not going to bore you with
> > them)
> > > I have realised that it is not what I really want to do. Now I am very
> > > interested in spirituality (humans and not machines) and in particular
> > > in consciousness. Neuroscience is directly related to it and also very
> > > fascinating. But I am not sure it's what I had in mind (at the
> > moment I
> > > am more interested in the spiritual side of consciousness but I have
> > > also started to read about neuroscience). Anyway, I did not want to
> > > waste many years of computer science and therefore I was looking
> > for a
> > > solution to put the two things together. That's why this post.
> > > So, is there a way to combine computer science and consciousness?
> > > I know this may sound a bit strange to you but if you have any idea,
> > > suggestion, comment, critic ..... I would really appreciate.
> > > Many thanks.
> > > Davide.
> > You may have a point there, lumping consciousness in with
> > spirituality, because for the most part people who think they are
> > studying consciousness are actually just playing word games.
> > Neuroscience is something completely different - it is biology, with
> > no connections to computer science beyond those we find in other
> > fields of science.
> > --
> > Joe
Thanks for mentioning Tonini, you reminded me of a fine book. It's a
good example of a scientific approach to the subject where computation
is seen as a tool rather than a substrate:
Gerald Edelman and Giulio Tononi (2001). A Universe Of Consciousness:
How Matter Becomes Imagination
Here's another I haven't read yet that comes highly recommended:
Gyorgy Buzsaki (2006). Rhythms of the Brain
Also, if you want to understand consciousness, consider the continuity
of brain structure/function across time and phyla. This one I can
Georg F. Striedter (2004). Principles of Brain Evolution
More information about the Neur-sci