Compositae vs. Asteraceae ??
cereoid at prodigy.net
Tue Aug 7 15:30:51 EST 2001
Not true. Only one name can be correct according to the current rules.
Principle IV of the International Code of Botanical Nomenclature (ICBN)
"Each taxonomic group with a particular circumscription, position, and rank
can bear only one correct name, the earliest that is in accordance with the
Rules, except in specified cases."
The old Jussieu plant names were allowed (tolerated) for many years to
placate the old guard botanists who insisted upon using them. It was
politics not botany that allowed their continued use. Now that those
individual have all long since passed away, the Jussieu names are to be
rejected in favor of plant family names in proper form. Before you cite
articles 18.5 and 18.6 in rebuttal, I would say that even though the Jussieu
names are validly published, they are in improper form and should be
rejected for that reason.
Look in Appendix IIB of the International Code of Botanical Nomenclature
(ICBN) for the list of conserved (accepted) plant family names. You will
find that the family name Asteraceae is conserved over the obsolete
----- Original Message -----
From: Bryan Ness <bness at puc.edu>
To: Cereoid* <cereoid at prodigy.net>;
<plant-ed at firstname.lastname@example.org>
Sent: Tuesday, August 07, 2001 7:46 PM
Subject: Re: Compositae vs. Asteraceae ??
> As a plant taxonomist I thought I better chime in on this one. Both names
> are actually correct. The name Asteraceae is correct by the current
> rules, but Compositae is also correct. Compositae is one of several
> so-called conserved names that are considered valid. These names are
> allowed as official exceptions to the normal rules because they have been
> of such long-standing use and banning them would cause too much
> confusion. It appears that retaining these names sometimes also causes
> Bryan Ness (bness at puc.edu) http://www.puc.edu/Faculty/Bryan_Ness/
> Office Phone: 707-965-6634 Department of Biology
> Home Phone: 707-965-2220 Pacific Union College
> FAX: 707-965-6390 Angwin, CA 94508
> !!Also see the Botany Site at http://botany.about.com
> Ants are so much like human beings as to be an embarrassment...They do
> everything but watch television. -- Lewis Thomas
More information about the Plant-ed