crying as a reaction

35002_4206 at uwovax.uwo.ca 35002_4206 at uwovax.uwo.ca
Thu Aug 5 12:20:30 EST 1993


In article <1336.kdraeger at soils.umn.edu_POPMail.PC_3.2.2>, kdraeger at SOILS.UMN.EDU ("Kathy Draeger") writes:
> 
>      I recently heard an interview with a scientist regarding crying. The 
> scientist had found that there was a great deal of adrenalin released in 
> the tears of females- more so than was found in males. There was no 
> speculation on why this adaption for adrenalin release is found 
> predominantly in females. Any suggestions??. I'm sorry that I can't 
> remember the name of the scientist.

I'm quite certain that 4 million years of gender differentiation -- both
in terms of physiology and the development of strategic roles -- have something
to do with it. At the risk of sounding sexist, men -- owing to our physique
and disposability (no big deal to the perpetuation of the species if our
numbers drop) -- have been sent by Mother Nature to do a lot of the `field
work' (whatever the hell that means). So what's this got to do with tears?
Well, image a group of proto-human men going out to hunt. Unbeknownst to the
rest of the party, the newest member of their proud brotherhood is a `crier'.
It wouldn't take long for this guy to turn on the tapworks. Hunting is ripe
with causes to cry: fear, confusion, embarrassment, anger, exhaustion, tragedy,
disappointment are all part of the ritual. Having a guy around who cries would
be extra baggage. (This would explain why men are often so insensitive)
You can add to this the fact that doing `field work' uses up a lot of adrenalin
-- which would also negate the need for tears.
As for crying amongst women, well, I can't see any reason for it not to happen.
Its perfectly healthy (though perhaps a bit disconcerting). I think men need to
become more sensitive. It seems we've dragged society into this primitive hunter
mindset that stoicism and displays of strength are the virtues of
professionalism.

Rob Coutant

 



More information about the Womenbio mailing list