abortion response

Joseph Aharchi mfja at uxa.ecn.bgu.edu
Fri Feb 16 21:40:27 EST 1996

anne at expert.cc.purdue.edu (Anne Carpenter) wrote:
> I wholeheartedly agree that we should not get into a discussion of
> abortion.  However, I had to comment...
> Someone posts the number for an abortion clinic.
> Someone (ED) posts the number for an adoption clinic and urges people
> considering abortion to consider adoption too.
> Then someone else tells ED that he has no right to tell us women how to
> live because he's a man.
> This is an interesting gender issue:
> Firstly, ED did *not* tell anyone how to live...reread the original post.
> Secondly, just because ED could never become pregnant doesn't mean that
> he has no right to decide upon the morality of abortion - 
> If a woman is infertile and will never be able to have children, does she not
> have the right to say that abortion is immoral (or moral, for that matter)?  
> Just because you wouldn't ever be in a situation yourself does not mean that
> you can't believe certain actions in that situation would be immoral.  Do 
> you see what I mean? 
> It seems like some women have learned nothing from years of 
> discrimination - the answer is not to discriminate against men, but to 
> let people have their say, male or female.
> Anne
I agree WHOLE-HEARTEDLY with Anne -- let EVERYONE, male or female have
their say.  HOWEVER, let NO ONE, male or female, try to enforce upon me
what to do with my body.

More information about the Womenbio mailing list