IUBio

death of the mind.

dan michaels feedbackdroids at yahoo.com
Sat Jul 17 11:48:33 EST 2004


"John Hasenkam" <johnh at faraway.> wrote in message news:<40f8dd2e at dnews.tpgi.com.au>...
> "dan michaels" <feedbackdroids at yahoo.com> wrote in message
> news:8d8494cf.0407161155.5b99e97a at posting.google.com...
> > "John Hasenkam" <johnh at faraway.> wrote in message
>  news:<40f7e6fb at dnews.tpgi.com.au>...
> >
> > >
> >
> > Hmmm, Wheeler plagiarizing Heinlein. Bad, bad, bad.
> 
> Ha! Was wondering if anyone would pick up the old scifi classic reference.
> Pity about the novel ending though, an avid scifi reader friend of mine said
> that was because the publishers were becoming impatient. It was me
> plagiarising Heinlein.
> 
> 
> > And as mentioned several times above, the 98% or so of the masses are
> > one thing, the other 2% are something else.
> >
> > We must endeavor not to suppress the minds of the 2nd group while
> > dealing with mundane issues regards the 1st group. Must'nt we, now.
> > ================
> 
> Oh I wish I knew how to do that.
> 


Well, I guess by your lack of responsiveness to the rest of my msg,
you're tacitly admitting that you "were" mixing up indoctrination vs
liberal-education of students with the conservative behavior of
peer-level scientists, in regards how they respond to new or changed
versions of "accepted" theories. Liberal vs indoctrinational
education, versus doctrinaire attitudes of working scientists. Very
different issues.

Regards whether or not to treat all students alongs the line of the
lowest common denominator, or not - of course, that's *THE* problem
every educator needs to learn to solve on his[her] own. As one who has
observed a number of teachers in the field, I'd say the lazy ones
don't try very hard to solve this. They're basically like the students
themselves who wish only to graduate, get a job, and then possibly
never read another book.

OTOH, you have the teachers who do try and find their way through the
issue - they're the ones you remember years later, of course, whereas
all the others are just a blur.

Regards this matter in general, all I can do is refer you to Skinnerd
himself .... the good teacher looks to instill the "positive reasons
for studying" into their students .... as someone else used to post
around here ....

> > Civilization has moved from an aversive control toward a positive
> > approach .... You hear claims occasionally that we've got to
> > start whipping our school boys and girls again, but this simply
> > reminds us that until very recently, education was very aversive ...
> > but there is a movement away from punishment, and an effort to find
> > positive reasons for studying. - B.F. Skinner



More information about the Neur-sci mailing list

Send comments to us at biosci-help [At] net.bio.net