""Jeff Houlahan"" <jeffhoul at unbsj.ca> wrote in message
news:1112872362.b87865a0jeffhoul at unbsj.ca...
Hi, Microbio members. Like many Biology departments in universities across
Canada, our university, the University of New Brunswick at Saint John, has
decided to phase out the comprehensive exam in favour of a proposal
defense/qualifying exam as part of the requirements for completion of a Ph.
D. The rationale for this, as we understand it, is that students should not
be expected to have a detailed understanding of the entire discipline of
biology. A proposal defense/qualifying exam is only expected to test a
student on areas relevant to their Ph. D. research. This is a concept we
support, but it does raise the concern that students could graduate with a
Ph. D. in Biology without understanding some very basic biological concepts
if those concepts are not relevant to their project. For example, students
doing research that has no explicit evolutionary context could graduate
without knowing the difference between evolution and natural selection. Our
discussion group has suggested that one way to deal with this is to develop
a list of 'The 50 things every biologist should know' and make those 50
topics fair game in a qualifying exam/proposal defence. Thus, our goal is
to put together such a list. We have put together a preliminary list of 60
different questions (maybe) every biologist should be able to answer (see
that list below), but we are looking for broader input. We would love to
hear from anybody who would like to add a question or questions to the list,
or make some comment about the questions that are already on the list.
Ultimately, we will be putting together a survey to rank the suggestions we
get and identify the '50 things every biologist should know' as ranked by
survey responses. We will distribute that list to this group when the
survey is complete. Thanks for any comments you can provide on this.
The UNBSJ Ecology discussion group
A. CHEMISTRY
1. What is an atom?
2. What is a molecule?
3. What causes water to be green?
4. What are the two laws of thermodynamics?
5. What are the four unique properties of water?
6. What three elements define organic compounds?
7. What is an element?
8. What is a protein
9. What is a carbohydrate?
10. What is a lipid?
B. MOLECULAR
11. What is DNA?
12. What is a gene?
13. What is natural selection?
13b. Are evolution and natural selection synonymous terms?
14. What is a chromosome?
15. What are the four principles of Mendelian genetics
16. What is a genome?
17. How is DNA replicated?
18. What is epistasis?
19. What are the sources of genetic variation?
20. What is epigenesis?
C. EVOLUTION
21. What does the Hardy-Weinberg Equilibrium predict, and what is the
importance of the model assumptions?
22. How have continents moved and how has that affected the formation and
distribution
of species?
23. What is evolution?
24. What is the difference between micro and macro-evolution?
25. Can you read a phylogenetic tree?
26. What are the kingdoms of living organisms?
27. Finish the following Kingdom, Phylum.
28. What is the "Evolutionary Synthesis"?
29. Is evolution progressive?
30. What comes first: the adaptation or the selective pressure?
31. What is meant by the "inheritance of acquired traits", who made this
claim, and why was he wrong?
32. What is the object of natural selection?
33. Are cladogenesis and anagenesis synonymous terms?
34. What is a phenotype?
D. CELLULAR
35. What is osmosis?
36. What are the key differences between prokaryotes and eukaryotes
37. What is mitosis and what happens during mitosis?
38. What is meiosis and what happens during meiosis?
39. What are the ? cell organelles and what are their functions?
40. What are the key differences between plant and animal cells?
41. What is a cell?
E. ENERGY/MATTER
42. What is photosynthesis?
43. What is glycolysis?
44. What is the Kreb's cycle?
45. How does energy flow and matter cycle?
46. What is a trophic level?
47. How does water cycle?
48. Can you describe the cycles for key nutrients (nitrogen, phosphorus,
carbon)
49. What is biomagnification?
F. ECOLOGY
50. What is the Theory of Island Biogeography?
51. What are r and K selected life histories?
52. What is an ecosystem?
G. GENERAL
53. What are Newton's Laws?
54. What are the key organs in the human body and what are their functions?
55. What are Theories, hypotheses and predictions and how do they differ?
56. What are the important plant structures and their functions?
57. What is homeostasis and why is it important?
58. What is the scientific method?
59. What is a confidence interval?
60. What is an ANOVA?
Excuse the cross posting - we are trying to get a diverse group of opinions.
---
No being inflamitory but surely these 60 items are all concepts which any
graduate Biologist would have fully grapsed in their first degree and which
would be expanded during broad Ph. D. level reading or has the standard
changed.
If you adding such things how about the difference between Fermentation and
oxidative respiration.
Prokayotic v Eukaryotic structure
or
What is an enzyme
What is an operon
What is the PCR reaction
What was the most important biological scientific discovery of the 20 C
What will be the most important biological discovery off the 21 C ..now that
will sort the grading out
Finally a pet annoiance ;
When is data actually non parametric ..now thats a good one :)
Best N10
Best N10
