The following is a modified duplication of a post that I intended to cross-post
to talk.origins AND bionet.molbio.evolution, but somehow it never made it to
Alright, here's a question for you geologists out there.
Young earth creationists, please do not bother.
PLEASE educate this molecular evolutionary biologist.
I am wondering; what serious values have been proposed for the age of earth?
In casual converstion, I usually hear values ca. 4.5 Billion years.
In a quick check of a few paleobotany texts (all I have at my immediate
disposal) this is close to what they cite in their "geological columns."
In a nutshell,on which isotopes are these based and what statistical errors
correspond to these measures?
In a recent paper in _Science_ (v257: 232-235, 10 July 1992), the authors
claim to have found fossil eukaryotic algae that are ca. 2.1 BY old. This
is striking to me because this lineage likely represents a fairly derived
eukaryotic lineage itself. In other words, there are a number of eukaryote
lineages which branched off before this one did. This makes these other euks
older than 2.1 BY. In fact, Archaezoa (euks with out mitochondria, ie:
_Giardia_, that wonderful intestinal parasite) are probably MUCH older than
the Algae they found (_Grypania_). Given this and that the root of the
tree of life is EVEN DEEPER (between eubacteria and
archaebacteria+eukaryotes), this seems to put "life" (ie: the common ancestor
of all life: the "progenote") fairly ancient, perhaps ca. 3.5 BYA.
This, as I read it, apparent ca. ONE billion year gap between the Earth's
origin and the origin of life is the impetus of this post. From a VERY
naive point of view, this doesn't seem very long. If in fact there
is significant statistical error associated with the Age of the Earth, or the
Dating of the fossils in question for that matter, perhaps there is a longer
time period between the Earth origin and Life origin. If not, are there any
problems with such an apparently limited time frame for evolution of life
Any primary literature (biology) and/or review/popular (geology) references
are much appreciated.
John Logsdon Department of Biology
Bloomington, IN 47405
(812) 855-6705 fax
jlogsdon at sunflower.bio.indiana.edu